I Became Guardian of My Twin Sisters After Mom Died — My Fiancée Pretended to Love Them Until I Heard What She Really Said

Following the unexpected loss of their mother, James’ fiancée takes on the role of guardian for his ten-year-old twin sisters.

However, as grief becomes ordinary and trust grows, he starts to learn a brutal reality that, if he doesn’t reveal it first, might shatter all he’s holding together.

I was a twenty-five-year-old structural engineer six months ago, with a wedding to organize, a half-paid honeymoon in Maui, and a fiancée who had already decided on the names of our future children.

Yes, I was stressed out by deadlines, expenses, a mother who texted me every hour with updates on the grocery list, and a variety of supplements to take.

“James, you work too much,” she would say. “And I’m proud of you! But I’m worried about your health, too. Which is why supplements and good food are going to be the order of the day.”

Stress, then. However, it was predictable, normal, and controllable.

Then, on her way to get birthday candles for my twin sisters Lily and Maya’s tenth birthday, my mother Naomi was murdered in an automobile accident. Suddenly, the burden of unexpected fatherhood overtook every aspect of my adult life.

The seating chart for the wedding? Ignored.

What about the save-the-dates? Awaiting.

The espresso maker for which we had signed up? Cancelled.

I became the only parent after being the oldest child. I used to design foundations, but now I’m a mother of two little girls with nowhere to go.

When Mom revealed that she was miraculously pregnant with the twins, our dad, Bruce, had left. I was close to fifteen. Since then, we had not heard from him. It was therefore more than simply mourning when Mom passed away.

It has to do with surviving. I was murmuring to myself, “Can I sign permission slips now?” while two frightened, quiet girls clutched their backpacks.

That same evening, I returned to Mom’s place. I left behind everything I considered to be a grownup, including my coffee grinder and apartment.

I did my best. However, Jenna? She made everything appear simple.

Two weeks following the funeral, Jenna moved in, stating that she wanted to assist. She prepared the girls’ school lunches. Their hair was braided by her. She performed lullabies that she had discovered on Pinterest.

In her glittering notepad, Maya entered her name and phone number as an additional emergency contact. Jenna wiped away a tear and muttered, “I finally have the little sisters I always dreamed of.”

I considered me fortunate. My fiancée was doing precisely what my mother would have wanted for the twins, and I believed she was an angel.

But I was mistaken, boy.

I returned home early from a site visit last Tuesday. By the time I pulled into the driveway, the sky had become dark and cloudy. The weather was constantly reminiscent of waiting rooms at hospitals.

From the outside, the house appeared serene. As usual, Lily’s muddy gardening gloves were nestled neatly on the porch rail, and Maya’s bike was still on the yard. I carefully unlocked the door so as not to wake anyone who could be taking a nap or working on their homework.

The smell of craft glue and cinnamon buns filled the corridor inside. I m

oved ahead, but stopped when I heard Jenna’s voice coming from the kitchen.

It was neither soft nor warm. Like a whisper coated in ice, it was low and slicing.

“Girls, you are not going to be staying here for long. So, don’t get too comfortable. James is doing what he can, but I mean…”

I went cold. What I was hearing was unbelievable.

“I’m not wasting the final years of my 20s raising someone else’s kids,” Jenna said. “A foster family would be much better for you anyway. At least they’ll know how to deal with your… sadness. Now, when the final adoption interview is scheduled, I want you both to say that you want to leave. Understand?”

There was no sound. Then a low, stifled voice.

“Don’t cry, Maya,” Jenna curtly said. “I’m warning you. If you cry again, I’ll take your notebooks and throw them away. You need to grow up before you keep writing your silly stories in them.”

A murmured “But we don’t want to leave,” Maya said. “We want to stay with James. He’s the best brother in the world.”

My stomach twisted.

“You don’t get to want anything. Go do your homework, girls. Hopefully, you’ll be out of my hair in a few weeks, and I can go back to my wedding planning. Don’t worry, you’ll still be invited, of course. But don’t think that you’ll be… bridesmaids or anything.”

I heard bare feet hurrying up the stairs. The door to the girls’ bedroom closed too forcefully a few seconds later.

I stood there, holding my breath as her words began to sink in. I was unable to even approach the kitchen. I wanted her to be unaware of my presence. All I wanted to hear was more. I had to know more.

Before I reacted, I needed to be certain.

When I heard Jenna again, I could tell she was on the phone with one of her friends because of the way her tone changed, like if she had switched a switch.

When Jenna stated, “They’re finally gone,” She sounded lighter suddenly, almost breathless, as if she had removed a mask. “Karen, I swear I’m losing my mind. I have to play perfect mom all day. And it’s exhausting.”

She let out a little laugh that I hadn’t heard in weeks. What had Karen said, I wondered? After a moment, her tone became more acerbic.

“He’s still dragging his feet on the wedding,” she added. “I know it’s because of the girls. But once he adopts them, they’re legally his problem, not mine. That’s why I need them gone. We have an interview coming up with the social worker soon.”

I steadied myself by pressing my hand against the wall.

“The house? The insurance money? It should be for us! I just need James to wake up and smell the coffee… and put my name on the deed.

And after that, I don’t really care what happens to those girls. I’ll make their lives miserable until he gives in. And then this naïve man will think it was his idea all along.”

My throat tightened around my breath. How was I going to wed this awful woman?

“I’m not raising someone else’s leftovers, Karen,” she replied. “I deserve so much more than this.”

I quietly closed the front door behind me after backing out. I had shaking hands.

I sat motionless inside the automobile. The image of me in the rearview mirror was strange: drawn, angry, and pallid.

I was suddenly struck by it.

This wasn’t a mistake or a weak point. This was something Jenna had been preparing for some time. Every compliment she offered the girls was a part of a plan, whether it was when she packed a lunch or braided their hair.

It had not originated from love.

I imagined Maya’s journals, piled on her desk, each with a season label and experiences she never shared.

I pictured Lily’s dirt-stained fingers murmuring to the marigold seeds as if they were magic as she pressed them carefully into the garden bed she had constructed next to the fence.

I recalled their gentle, synchronized good-night greetings, which seemed to be a spell to keep each other safe as they slept.

After witnessing all of it, Jenna felt burdened.

I sat there, clenching my teeth and twisting my gut while holding onto the driving wheel. My heart was racing, not only from anger but also from the pain of realizing how nearly I had given my entire life to the wrong person.

This was the end of Jenna’s involvement in our story, so there wouldn’t be a fight.

After a short drive around the block, I pulled over to grab some pizza for the girls’ supper. I then entered again as if nothing had happened.

“Hey, honey! I’m home.”

Jenna came running up, grinning, and kissed me like if nothing were wrong. She was dishonest and had a coconut scent.

I sighed and ran a hand over my face one evening after the girls had gone to bed.

“Jenna… maybe you were right, babe.”

She tilted her head and questioned, “About what?”

“About the girls. Maybe… maybe I can’t do this. Maybe I should give them up. Maybe we should find a family who will take care of them. They need a mother… not us… we’re substitutes, nothing more.”

When she understood what I was saying, Jenna’s eyes brightened and she blinked slowly.

She said, “Oh, sweetheart,” “That’s the mature thing to do. It’s the right thing for all of us.”

“Yes, Jen. And maybe… we shouldn’t wait on our wedding. Losing my mom made me realize that we don’t have time to waste. So let’s just do it. Let’s get married!”

She yelled, “Are you serious, James?”

“I am. I really am.”

“Oh my goodness! Yes, James! Let’s do it. This weekend — small, simple, whatever we want.”

I gave a headshake.

“No, let’s do it bigger. Let’s invite everyone! And make it a fresh start for us, honey. Your family, my mom’s friends, the neighbors, colleagues… everyone!”

Her face could have broken if she had grinned any more.

Before Jenna even brushed her teeth the following morning, she was on the phone with florists. She reserved a ballroom, chose a hotel downtown, and shared a picture of the ring along with the following caption:

“Our forever starts now. James & Jenna, forever.”

I assured the girls that I would never desert them in the interim. I then placed my own calls.

The hotel ballroom glistened in that extravagant manner that Jenna loved. Every table had white linens strewn over it, and glass vases held floating candles that flickered.

Near the stage, Jenna’s cousin performed a tune she had practiced on the piano.

Glowing in a white lace gown, Jenna stood close to the entryway. Her makeup was flawless, her hair brushed up. It appeared as though she already thought the night was hers.

She smiled, hugged, and kissed cheeks as she drifted from one visitor to another. She turned to Maya and brushed a lock of hair behind her ear after pausing for a moment to adjust the bow on Lily’s dress.

“You girls look perfect,” she remarked, her grin falling short of her eyes.

Maya gave me a look and nodded.

Last fall, my parents helped me choose a navy suit, which I wore. There was still a hint of her perfume on it. A tiny bouquet made from wildflowers she picked outside the hotel was held by Lily, who was standing to my right.

Maya was standing to my left, gripping a pen with pink glitter.

Jenna raised the microphone, clinked her glass, and grinned at the audience.

“Thank you all for coming! Tonight, we’re celebrating love, family, and —”

I took a step nearer and touched her shoulder tenderly.

“Actually, babe, I’ll take it from here.”

My fiancée gave me the microphone without saying a word, but her smile wavered a little.

I took a tiny black remote control out of my jacket.

“Everyone,” I said as I turned to look at everyone. “We’re not just here to celebrate a wedding. We’re here to reveal who we really are.”

The projector behind us sparked to life.

The screen behind us came to life when I clicked the first file.

On the corner, the timestamp read “Tuesday Afternoon — Kitchen Camera”. The audio was crystal clear despite the poor, black-and-white video.

Jenna’s voice, careless and harsh, filled the hall.

“The house? The insurance money? It should be for us! I just need James to wake up and smell the coffee… and put my name on the deed. And after that, I don’t really care what happens to those girls. I’ll make their lives miserable until he gives in. And then this naïve man will think it was his idea all along.”

The room echoed with a gasp. A glass broke somewhere.

I paused it after letting it play for a few more seconds. My voice stayed calm, even as my hands tightened around the mic.

“My mom had nanny cams in the house. She installed them back when she worked long hours and had babysitters for Lily and Maya. I forgot they were even there until that day. This isn’t a setup. This isn’t a joke. This is Jenna, speaking freely.”

I clicked once more. Jenna’s voice was heard in another clip, this time addressing the girls directly.

“Don’t cry, Maya,” Jenna curtly said. “I’m warning you. If you cry again, I’ll take your notebooks and throw them away. You need to grow up before you keep writing your silly stories in them.”

A murmured “But we don’t want to leave,” Maya said. “We want to stay with James. He’s the best brother in the world.”

Lily’s hand slipped into mine. Maya didn’t look away, not even once.

“That’s not — James, that’s out of context! I was venting! You weren’t supposed to —”

Advertisement I turned to face her and said, “I heard everything,” “You weren’t planning a future. You were planning a betrayal. You used my sisters, and you lied to me.”

“You can’t do this to me, James! Not in front of everyone.”

I nodded to the security guard and said, “I just did… and anyway, you did it to yourself,”

Jenna cried out, “James, you’re ruining my life!”

“You were going to ruin theirs, Jenna. You deserve every horrible thing that’s coming your way.”

Jenna’s mother stayed seated, but her father shook his head and walked away.

Word spread swiftly.

The video found its way into every circle Jenna and I had ever been a part of. Jenna tried to recover, saying that the clips were altered or taken out of context. She posted a long, sad video on Facebook about “being misunderstood” and the “pressure getting the best of her.”

Nobody took her seriously.

She appeared outside the house three nights later. She screamed my name as if it still had significance while she was barefoot and covered in mascara. I waited inside the front hallway, arms crossed, gazing through the peephole until the police arrived.

The next morning, I filed the restraining order. I had to keep my sisters safe.

A week later, the girls’ adoption was finalized.

While in the judge’s office, Maya sobbed softly. It wasn’t loud or messy — just delicate tears that ran down her cheeks as she signed her name on the paperwork. Leaning forward, Lily gave her a tissue.

“We won’t be separated now,” Lily declared.

My heart ached. It was only then that I became aware of their anxieties.

We had spaghetti for supper that evening. Lily gave the sauce a stir. Maya held the parmesan as if it were a microphone and danced about the kitchen. I gave them permission to play their music loudly.

We sat down at last, and Maya tapped my wrist.

She said, “Can we light a candle for Mommy?”

“Of course.”

Lily ignited it herself and said something in a whisper that I missed. She snuggled into my arm after we finished our meal.

She remarked, “We knew you’d choose us,”

I forcefully gulped.

I opened my mouth to speak, but nothing came out. I thus didn’t act. I simply allowed the tears to fall. I allowed them to witness my tears.

They remained silent. With their hands gently resting on my arms like anchors, my younger sisters simply sat there, one on either side of me.

We were secure. We were authentic. We were also at home.